EVP of AI @ DonerColle | HowTo Transform A Creative Agency With AI

September 24, 2026

Doug Guttenberg, EVP of AI at DonerColle Partners, on building a AI team inside a creative agency

Doug Guttenberg owns AI transformation at DonerColle Partners, a creative agency, and he's never been a developer. Since early 2024, he's built a team of about 15 engineers and creative technologists.

EVP of AI @ DonerColle | HowTo Transform A Creative Agency With AI

Guest

Doug Guttenberg

Doug Guttenberg

Connect on LinkedIn

Executive VP of AI Innovation and Delivery

DonerColle Partners

Doug Guttenberg leads AI transformation at DonerColle Partners, a creative marketing and advertising agency. He built the agency's technology team from a small internal task force starting in early 2024.

Host

Josh Anderson

Connect on LinkedIn

Field CTO, Revelo

Josh Anderson is Revelo's Field CTO and the host of Tech Teams Today. He is also CTO at Reclaim and co-hosts The Meta-Cast podcast, and he has spent his career building and leading engineering teams.

About this episode

Doug Guttenberg runs AI transformation at DonerColle Partners, a creative agency, and he's never been a developer. He joined at the start of 2024 and built a team of about 15 engineers and creative technologists, most of whom surfaced from an internal task force he started with a small monthly experimentation budget. The team spans front-end developers, video studio people, and folks who work with their hands.

Doug walks through how the task force worked: members took personal or client problems, experimented on a monthly cadence, then reported back. The one rule that kept it productive was that nothing got shown to the broader agency unless it tied to something tangible. The people who stayed most committed became the foundation of the current team.

The conversation gets into a few assumptions Doug thinks are wrong right now. Juniors aren't ahead of seniors on AI, he says; the advantage people assume they have isn't showing up in practice. He also argues that the cost of switching models is mostly mental baggage carried over from switching databases or email providers, and that you can transfer your preferences from one model to another faster than you'd expect.

Doug adds orchestration to Josh's list of discernment, taste, and judgment as the skill that separates useful AI output from statistical average slop. He explains it as giving an LLM context, instructions, and constraints before asking it to produce anything, not just opening a chat window and asking a question. He's building and using MCPs personally and sees context connectivity as the thing that will change how people work together, not just how individuals do their own jobs faster.

Juniors don't know how to use AI any better than seniors do at the moment is one thing that I have been discovering. Not that they're not brilliant and bring different perspective. That's what you bring juniors in for the first place.

—

Doug Guttenberg

Executive VP of AI Innovation and Delivery

DonerColle Partners

Chapters

  • 00:00 Intro
  • 01:26 Shape and makeup of Doug's 15-person team
  • 03:13 What it actually means to bring AI into a creative agency
  • 05:08 Expectation inflation and where the market is landing
  • 07:02 How the internal task force became a real team
  • 15:50 Model switching costs less than you think
  • 20:27 Why juniors aren't ahead of seniors on AI
  • 27:52 Orchestration as the skill beyond taste and judgment
  • 35:00 Lightning round: GIF, leadership books, and first product shipped

Topics

  • How a small monthly experimentation budget grew into a 15-person tech team
  • The one filter that stopped the task force from becoming a string of cool demos
  • Why juniors aren't ahead of seniors on AI adoption right now
  • Why switching models costs less than engineers think it does
  • Orchestration as the missing skill beyond taste and judgment
  • Why building and using MCPs is the path to real workflow transformation
  • The 2 traits Doug hires for: curiosity and a sense of urgency

Be our next guest

Leading an engineering team? Come tell us what you've learned.

Apply to be a guest